Public Hearing to be held for Proposed Boggs Township Landfill

CLEARFIELD – The state’s Department of Environmental Protection will conduct a public hearing for the proposed Camp Hope Run Landfill in Boggs Township, announced the Clearfield County Commissioners at Tuesdays’ regular meeting.

The public hearing has been scheduled for 7 p.m. Jan. 22 at the Lighthouse Evangelical Church in West Decatur. The commissioners also invited community members to attend the public hearing. If anyone wishes to speak, the commissioners ask that they come prepared to present their testimony and written documents.

“We want to be heard,” said Joan Robinson-McMillen. Commissioner Mark B. McCracken added, “This will be our one opportunity to make our feelings known about the [detrimental] impact this landfill would have on Clearfield County.”

The public hearing was scheduled after Commissioner Chairman John A. Sobel and Robinson-McMillen went to the DEP offices in Williamsport last week and met with representatives regarding the proposed landfill.  Last month, the commissioners announced they had written the DEP to request that it conduct a public hearing for the proposed landfill.

PA Waste LLC has proposed constructing a landfill that would be located on an 845-acre facility boundary along state Route 153. It would be double-lined and able to receive 5,000 tons of waste daily for the next 25 years, according to previous reports.

In an Aug. 31 letter, the DEP notified the county that it had completed the Environmental Assessment Process for PA Waste’s application for a new municipal waste landfill in Boggs Township. The DEP evaluated the information contained in the application and determined the benefits of the proposal had outweighed the known or potential harms, according to Sobel.

During a Sept. 11 board meeting, Sobel said the permit process would proceed with the technical review of the information contained in the application. He said the DEP may perform additional balancing of the benefits and harms during the technical review of the application if additional information not previously considered should come to the DEP’s attention.

After a Nov. 13 board meeting, Robinson-McMillen said the commissioners continued to have concerns about the DEP’s decision. She said they were even more concerned about how quickly the DEP had recently proceeded with the proposed landfill permit without any acknowledgment of the county’s concerns.

The commissioners stated their concerns in a Sept. 12 report. Robinson-McMillen said the county sits right along Interstate 80 and if constructed, it would generate the additional traffic of 250 trucks, six days per week. She said these trucks would be coming off I-80 at exit 120, traveling down state Route 879, which she noted is a scenic byway.

From there, she said the trucks would travel across the SR 879 bypass off Park Avenue Extension and pass by the Lawrence Park Village Apartment Complex en route to Boggs Township. She said this raises concerns because there would be children who are getting on and off school buses at the apartment complex.

“Lawrence Township is going to be more affected than Boggs Township,” she said. “The township and county are going to bear the burden. And, people who are shopping at Lowe’s and Wal-Mart are going to be weaving in and out of truck traffic.”

McCracken said this board and the previous board have been steadfast in their opposition and will continue to be. Like Robinson-McMillen, he voiced concerns related to the influx in truck traffic.

According to him, a traffic study hasn’t been conducted and if the landfill is constructed, there would be dangers on SR 879 off I-80, where there are new restaurants and hotels in Lawrence Township.

“This is already a congested area,” he said.

McCracken also expressed concerns about it creating even more congestion in the areas of the I-80 on and off ramps; the U.S. Route 322 on ramp to SR 879; the trucks climbing the hill along the SR 879 bypass; and the SR 879/Park Avenue Extension off ramp. He said significant upgrades would be required to Park Avenue Extension.

“I think the fact it’s a scenic byway should have been considered. It’s a total disregard to the Lawrence Township area,” he said. He pointed out that the county had completed its 10-year update to its municipal solid waste management plan and properly advertised such. He said PA Waste didn’t submit a proposal.

“There’s no benefit to Clearfield County because they’re not in our plan,” he said. “There’s no trash disposal benefit for the county for at least 10 years.”

According to McCracken, PA Waste doesn’t have any compliance history, which raises serious concerns about its ability to even operate a landfill. Plus, he said there isn’t any need for additional landfill space in central Pennsylvania.

Robinson-McMillen said if constructed, the proposed landfill isn’t going to hold waste from Clearfield County. She said it would be hauled in from New York, New Jersey and Philadelphia.

“You have to ask why they would want to truck four-and-a-half to five hours to Clearfield County to dispose of waste. Why is that? Why are we allowing it? she asked. McCracken replied, “If we had a vote, we wouldn’t.”

On Nov. 13, McCracken said the county presented the DEP with information years ago that outlined their concerns and the potential harms if the Camp Hope Run Landfill would be constructed in Boggs Township. He said these documents have been removed from the package of information that’s being reviewed by the DEP.

In addition, he said they were verbally advised that the landfill proposal has been transferred from the DEP’s Williamsport office to the main office located in Harrisburg. Robinson-McMillen said this typically isn’t standard procedure for the DEP and it appears this permit application is on what she described as “the fast track.”

However, when contacted Nov. 13 by, the DEP issued this statement:

“The department approved the Environmental Assessment (harms vs. benefits) for this proposed landfill on Aug. 31 and is now engaged in our technical review of the municipal waste landfill permit application, which will eventually result in a decision to approve or deny the permit,” said Daniel Spadoni, community relations coordinator.

“There was never a transfer of this application review from Harrisburg to Williamsport. The application was originally submitted to the DEP Northcentral Regional Office in Williamsport as required and it has remained here. I cannot be [any] clearer than that.”

County Solicitor Kim Kesner said the DEP has not been communicating with the county and providing answers to its direct questions. He said obviously, the commissioners are a stakeholder and in the past, they have engaged in “informal discussions” regarding their concerns with representatives of the DEP office in Williamsport.

Kesner said the commissioners were surprised by the Aug. 31 letter in which DEP advised it had found the benefits had outweighed the harms. McCracken said in Williamsport, the DEP officials had their own concerns so far as where the waste would be coming from to be disposed of in Boggs Township.

Kesner said the DEP originally denied the PA Waste permit application based on “suitability.” He said that the DEP had acknowledged that there was already “too much landfill capacity” in Pennsylvania, which resulted in “heightened scrutiny.”

“There was so much going to be hurting Pennsylvania,” he said. Kesner said PA Waste appealed the DEP’s denial to the state’s Environmental Hearing Board, where the judge overruled the DEP’s decision, as it applied a regulation that had been amended.

“It was dormant after that. We didn’t hear anything and then we get this letter. It was a surprise,” said Robinson-McMillen. She said at one point, the commissioners had scheduled a meeting with DEP officials to discuss their concerns, which the DEP canceled.


LHU Awarded Accreditation of Business Administration and Accounting Programs
Vote Now for Pennsylvania's 2013 River of the Year

2 thoughts on “Public Hearing to be held for Proposed Boggs Township Landfill

  1. morcho

    Wait a minute D hold that thought when tourists come, commodes flush, litter lies as feed for the white tail, possum and crow and new sewer plants will run full bore a McDonalds goes up and the money rolls in woo or wow? There are so many ski resorts being planned for Clearfield County and Chief Red Cloud’s casino’s placed throughout the county will help with the crime rate and the new psychiatric complex to handle the gambling problems. Now, that’s a here is another positive thought more prison guards for the required new prisons maybe there is a light a glimmer for good paying jobs sometimes you can shoot yourself in the foot another positive for the new hospital, tourism and the gate way to the wilds. Oh no! building requires land man a what a bummer and I was getting such a high on the Scenic Byway out of Lawrence Township. Well, bubbles do burst?

  2. dwalker

    Dear Commissioners –

    Can you start naming some projects you may actually support, rather than everything you oppose? You have targeted one of the area’s major employers, the Shawville Power Plant, which will most likely be closed within the next three years and take 300 jobs with it. This is just one of the countless projects you are trying to put a stop to. You all have good jobs, but others don’t.

    Government supported ethanol wasn’t the answer. Tourism isn’t the answer. And if you keep opposing everything, a landfill will be the only option, and you may be the only ones living in the county when it happens.

    Please, let’s focus our energy on what we do want rather than what we don’t. Otherwise, I ask you to turn the lights out when you are the last ones to leave the county.

Leave a Reply